| Long Live Shah
Long Live Reza Shah
Long Live Mosadegh
Long Live Amir Kabir
Long Live Khomeini
Death to Islamic Republic
Death to Shah
Death to Khomeini
Death to … (feel free and fill in the blank!)
Long live (Zend'e BaAd), Death to (Mord'e BaAd); an all or nothing attitude.
Our history is filled with black or white, yes or no, Zend'e baAd or Mord'e
BaAd and as I like to refer to it a single political party culture (tak
Hezbi). Are
we truly ready for a multi-party political system? Before we can answer this
question we need to perhaps agree as to what a multi-party political system
requires and entails.
Thomas Sowell in his book titled:
The Vision of the Anointed: Self-Congratulation As a Basis for Social Policy
has
a statement that to most people appears as common sense but yet its simplicity
and depth
of meaning requires much to think about. He states:
"
We are all the same except for our differences and we are all different except
for our similarities".
Let us think about this statement. In Iran, especially
during the last 50 years what have we done to our country as citizens of
this great nation?
Let us sit
back and think!
If I am a monarchist I feel that what Shah and Reza Shah did was absolutely
right and no other way should be tolerated. If I belong to Jebh'e Melli I
feel that
what Mosadegh did was absolutely right and nothing he did was wrong. If I
am a supporter of Islamic Republic I feel that Khomeini was Imam and whatever
he
did was absolutely right and whatever the current government is doing is
absolutely correct.
But is that truly the case? Is that a matter of our own prejudices or are
they truly realities? Can we truly progress as a nation if we all hold so
tightly to our own black or white sense of reality? If we were to truly hold
to this
type of attitude in our own personal relationships, in dealing with our wives,
husbands, children, or colleagues at work, would we be able to succeed in
our
family or business?
What if we try a little exercise? What if we try real hard to identify only
one action that whoever we oppose has done that is right. For example:
- If you believe in monarchy, please identify one action of Mosadegh that
was right.
- If you belong to Jebh'e Melli, please identify one action that Reza
Shah did was right.
- If you believe in the 1979 revolution and the Islamic Republic, please
identify one action that Mohammad Reza Shah did that was right.
- Did Bakhtiar do anything that was good for our country?
All we ask is for you to identify a SINGLE action. Not two actions, but a
simple action.
Please realize that for us to be true to our own conscious we have to put
ourselves in that time period, feel the constraints facing the very person
we oppose, and
then think if what they did was, in their opinion something they thought
that was going to serve the country or they maliciously wanted to hurt
our nation.
The list goes on and on… All we want to do is to find a common
ground. Help in finding a platform of commonality amongst all of us. Let
us do this
against all of our prejudices and beliefs.
In a multi-party system we have
to learn to find common ground and build on our similarities. Our differences
should make us diverse and help us
be prepared against unforeseen surprises perhaps not seen by the majority.
My friends, Galileo was one person while the rest of the world was adamantly
certain that he was wrong. Today we know it was the rest of the world
that was wrong and one person was right. It is very well possible that
we are wrong and
the very person that we adamantly fight against is right. Let us all
keep
an open mind and embrace the differences amongst ourselves. Let us build
on our
similarities.
We encourage you to take a second and vote to the series
of questions that are posed on this very subject. We want to simply show
if there
are any common
grounds
amongst us.
One last thought- I sure hope one day we all come to terms with this
simple concept that Iran belongs to the living. The living can only decide
for the
living. The
dead have no rights. Democracy is the government of the living by the
living for the living. Decisions made by the dead can not govern the
living! We
should let go of our dead and concentrate on ourselves, Iran of today
and today's Iranians.
We have to have the courage to accept that our children have as much
right as we have now to decide for what is right for them.
Let the dialog begin |